The dossier of a worksite
Document a restoration or a conservation intervention, with the consent of the person who directs it: the condition before, the choices made and why.
Why this assignment, and why publishing it matters for your students: the article for conservation students.
The brief
- Objective
- Document a restoration or a conservation intervention, with the consent of the person who directs it: the condition before, the choices made and why.
- Output
- A place entry with before-and-after photographs and the choices explained
- Length
- 800 to 1,200 words
- Materials
- Written consent of whoever directs the works
- Dated photographs before and after, taken by the student or released by the worksite
- A short account of the choices and of the reasons given for them
- At least two published or technical sources
- The teacher marks
- The precision of the condition record and the reasoning behind the choices.
- The desk checks
- Every fact against its sources, and the sources themselves
- The rights on every image: who took it, under what licence, with whose permission
- The position on the map, and none at all for sites without a guard
- That nothing carrying the student’s name goes online before they have read it and approved it
The marking grid
Four criteria, four levels. Use it as it is, or adapt it to your own scale.
| Criterion | Excellent | Good | Sufficient | Not yet |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Accuracy and sources | Every fact is sourced; the sources are varied, checkable and used critically. | Facts are sourced and checkable; one or two minor points rest on a single source. | Most facts are sourced; some claims need a source the desk has to ask for. | Key facts are unsourced or wrong; the piece cannot be published as it stands. |
| Visual documentation | Photographs and drawings show what the text explains; captions are complete and credited. | Images are relevant and credited; one or two add little to the text. | Images are present but loosely tied to the text, or captions are thin. | Images are missing, unusable, or their rights are unclear. |
| Clarity for a non-specialist reader | A reader who has never been there understands the place and why it matters. | Clear overall; a few passages assume knowledge the reader does not have. | Understandable with effort; jargon and structure get in the way. | The reader cannot follow the piece without specialist knowledge. |
| Rights and places | Permissions are stated, licences correct, sensitive positions withheld. | Rights are respected; one permission or licence needs to be written down. | Some rights questions are open and must be settled before publication. | The piece uses material without permission, or exposes a vulnerable site. |
Download the grid (Word)Download the grid (PDF)
The four weeks
Site visit and collection
Students visit the place, take their photographs and drawings, and gather the sources.
Draft sent
Each student sends the draft from their own account, with the images and the sources.
Review by the desk
The editors review every piece within five working days and send back their questions.
Publication
The pieces go online under each student’s name, and the teacher receives the list of links.
What the desk commits to
- Review within five working days, for groups of up to 40 students.
- One editorial contact for the course, the same address for every question, from the first draft to the last link.
- A report at the end of the course, sent to the teacher, with every published piece and its link.
What a finished piece looks like
Rights and places
- Can I publish photographs of a restoration site?
- With the consent of whoever directs the works, and outside the rules that restrict images of cultural property where they apply. Say who authorised access and when the photographs were taken.
Contributors must be eighteen or older; they confirm it when they enter the department’s code.
Teach with CHO
Tell us about your course →Begin your message with “Teach with CHO” and tell us the institution, the course, how many students, and the semester.
